The market size trap
Investors often start with the size of the market. It is an understandable habit. A large market leaves room for a large company. But a large, stable market also has well-funded incumbents, established distribution and customers who are reasonably satisfied. A startup entering it has to fight on the incumbents' terms.
The companies that come to define markets usually start somewhere else: at a point where something in a large system has broken.
What a dislocation looks like
A dislocation is a change that makes the existing way of doing something suddenly worse, more expensive or impossible, and opens room for a new approach. We see four common sources:
- A cost curve collapses. When the cost of computing, storage, sensors, batteries or model inference falls far enough, products that were impossible become cheap.
- A rule changes. New regulation can create obligations nobody is equipped to meet, or open a market that was closed.
- A platform shifts. New infrastructure, such as instant payments or capable AI models, changes what can be built on top of it.
- Behaviour changes. A shift in how people work, buy or communicate leaves incumbents serving an old pattern.
Why dislocations favour startups
Incumbents are built for the world before the change. Their products, pricing, organisations and incentives are tuned to it. When the ground moves, they have to unwind what made them successful, and that takes time. A startup begins with no such commitments and can build for the new world from the first day.
The window does not last forever. Incumbents adapt and new competitors arrive. The founders who win usually saw the change early, often because they were close to it, and moved before it was obvious.
How founders can recognise one
We ask founders three questions, and we suggest founders ask them of themselves:
- What specifically has changed? Name the cost, rule, platform or behaviour, and when it changed.
- Who is hurt by the change? Which customers now have a problem they did not have before, or an opportunity they could not reach?
- Why can't incumbents respond quickly? What about their business makes the new approach hard for them?
A clear answer to all three is one of the strongest signals we know. It tells us the founder understands not only the product, but the moment.
We don’t invest in companies. We invest in moments of clarity.
Important information. This publication is provided for general information only and reflects the views of Cash Capital as of its date. It is not investment, legal, tax or accounting advice, and it is not an offer to sell, or a solicitation of an offer to buy, any security or any interest in any fund.
Figures, statistics and company information are drawn from third-party sources that we believe to be reliable, including news reports, data providers and company announcements. We have not independently verified them, and some may be estimates, preliminary, reported rather than confirmed, or later revised. Cash Capital makes no representation or warranty as to their accuracy, completeness or timeliness and accepts no liability for any loss arising from reliance on them. Readers should consult the original sources and their own advisers before making any decision.
Predictions, outlooks and other forward-looking statements are opinions about uncertain future events and may not occur. We do not undertake to update this publication. Companies named are used for illustration only; unless stated otherwise they are not Cash Capital portfolio companies, and naming them does not imply any relationship, endorsement or recommendation. See our Terms & Disclosures.